• About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Login
    • ObGFirst
  • COVID-19
  • Alerts
  • OB
  • 2T US Atlas
  • The Genome
  • GYN
    • GYN
    • Sexual Health
  • Primary Care
  • Your Practice
  • GrandRounds
  • My Bookshelf
  • Now@ObG
  • Media
About Us Contact Us Login ObGFirst
  • COVID-19
  • Alerts
  • OB
  • 2T US Atlas
  • The Genome
  • GYN
    • GYN
    • Sexual Health
  • Primary Care
  • Your Practice
  • GrandRounds
  • My Bookshelf
  • Now@ObG
  • Media
Your Practice

New York Unanimously Passes Bill to Bar Pelvic Exams Without Consent

image_pdfFavoriteLoadingFavorite

NY state has passed legislation that prohibits the performance of a pelvic examination on an anesthetized or unconscious patient without the oral or written informed consent specific to the pelvic examination by the patient or a patient representative. According to the NY law, the performance of a pelvic examination must be within the scope of care for the surgical procedure or diagnostic examination scheduled to be performed on the patient and the patient has already consented to such care. Performance of such exams without consent would be considered professional misconduct for both performance and supervision domains. Exceptions are made for medically necessary diagnostic or treatment purposes when the patient requires immediate medical attention and an attempt to secure consent would delay treatment, thus increasing risk to the patient’s life or health. New York is one of a minority of states with such legislation. Other states without such legislation claim that either there is evidence lacking that this practice is indeed occurring or that hospitals already have consenting procedures in place.

In 2005, the Association of American Medical Colleges had deemed “performing pelvic examinations on women under anesthesia, without their knowledge or approval …unethical and unacceptable.” In 2011 (reaffirmed in 2017), ACOG released a committee opinion that states explicitly

Pelvic examinations on an anesthetized woman that offer her no personal benefit and are performed solely for teaching purposes should be performed only with her specific informed consent obtained before her surgery.

Despite the above guidance and years of concern, reports still surfaced that this practice was ongoing, triggering legislative action. While performing pelvic exams without consent has been deemed unacceptable by professional colleges and state houses, proficiency in the performance and interpretation of a pelvic exam is still a requisite medical skill. In certain clinical scenarios, a thorough gynecologic assessment may be lifesaving. Therefore, many medical schools have moved toward paid volunteers or pelvic trainers to ensure that students receive adequate training.

A billed was passed in Florida (2020) that prohibits practitioners and medical students from performing pelvic examinations on patients without written consent from the patients or the patients’ guardians. This applies beyond a setting that would require anesthesia. ACOG has responded to the bill and states

While this legislation may have been well intended in its original form, it was changed very late in the legislative session to broaden the original intended scope

The actual impact will be to interfere in the patient–physician relationship and to hold women’s health care to a different standard than other care

ACOG opposes this intrusion in the patient–physician relationship and will be working with other allied groups who are impacted by this new law to repeal this requirement

Learn More – Primary Sources

ACOG Committee Opinion 500: Professional Responsibilities in Obstetric-Gynecologic Medical Education and Training

JAMA Forum: Teaching Pelvic Examination Under Anesthesia Without Patient Consent

The New York State Senate

As other states require consent for pelvic exams, Connecticut bill stalls

ACOG Statement on New Florida Law Requiring Written Consent for Pelvic Examinations

Want to hear about the latest clinical summaries via ObG Insider?

Get Your Free e-Newsletter »

image_pdfFavoriteLoadingFavorite
< Previous
All Your Practice Posts
Next >

Related ObG Topics:

Traditional vs. Simulation Training for Laparoscopic Salpingectomy
Need for Paid Parental Leave and Resident Physician Training Requirements – Often at Odds
Does Resident Participation in OB/GYN Surgeries Impact Outcomes?
Does Presence of Senior Obstetricians Impact Mode of Delivery?

Sections

  • COVID-19
  • Alerts
  • OB
  • GYN
    • GYN
    • Sexual Health
  • 2T US Atlas
  • The Genome
  • Primary Care
  • Your Practice
  • Grand Rounds
  • My Bookshelf
  • Now@ObG
  • Media

Are you an
ObG Insider?

Get specially curated clinical summaries delivered to your inbox every week for free

  • Site Map/
  • © ObG Project/
  • Terms and Conditions/
  • Privacy/
  • Contact Us/
© ObG Project
SSL Certificate


  • Already an ObGFirst Member?
    Welcome back

    Log In

    Want to sign up?
    Get guideline notifications
    CME Included

    Sign Up

Get Guideline Alerts Direct to Your Phone
Try ObGFirst Free!

Sign In

Lost your password?

Sign Up for ObGFirst and Stay Ahead

  • - Professional guideline notifications
  • - Daily summary of a clinically relevant
    research paper
  • - Includes 1 hour of CME every month

ObGFirst Free Trial

Already a Member of ObGFirst®?

Please log in to ObGFirst to access the 2T US Atlas

Password Trouble?

Not an ObGFirst® Member Yet?

  • - Access 2T US Atlas
  • - Guideline notifications
  • - Daily research paper summaries
  • - And lots more!
ObGFirst Free Trial

Media - Internet

Computer System Requirements

OBG Project CME requires a modern web browser (Internet Explorer 10+, Mozilla Firefox, Apple Safari, Google Chrome, Microsoft Edge). Certain educational activities may require additional software to view multimedia, presentation, or printable versions of their content. These activities will be marked as such and will provide links to the required software. That software may be: Adobe Flash, Apple QuickTime, Adobe Acrobat, Microsoft PowerPoint, Windows Media Player, or Real Networks Real One Player.

Disclosure of Unlabeled Use

This educational activity may contain discussion of published and/or investigational uses of agents that are not indicated by the FDA. The planners of this activity do not recommend the use of any agent outside of the labeled indications.

The opinions expressed in the educational activity are those of the faculty and do not necessarily represent the views of the planners. Please refer to the official prescribing information for each product for discussion of approved indications, contraindications, and warnings.

Disclaimer

Participants have an implied responsibility to use the newly acquired information to enhance patient outcomes and their own professional development. The information
presented in this activity is not meant to serve as a guideline for patient management. Any procedures, medications, or other courses of diagnosis or treatment discussed or suggested in this activity should not be used by clinicians without evaluation of their patient’s conditions and possible contraindications and/or dangers in use, review of any applicable manufacturer’s product information, and comparison with recommendations of other authorities.

Jointly provided by

NOT ENOUGH CME HOURS

It appears you don't have enough CME Hours to take this Post-Test. Feel free to buy additional CME hours or upgrade your current CME subscription plan

Subscribe

JOIN OBGFIRST AND GET CME/CE CREDITS

One of the benefits of an ObGFirst subscription is the ability to earn CME/CE credits from the ObG entries you read. Tap the button to learn more about ObGFirst

Learn More
Leaving ObG Website

You are now leaving the ObG website and on your way to PRIORITY at UCSF, an independent website. Therefore, we are not responsible for the content or availability of this site